When investing in a new roof, the quality of the warranty can be as important as the quality of the materials and installation. Several reputable Bloomington, Indiana, roofing companies offer varying levels of protection, from basic labor coverage to industry-leading, manufacturer-backed warranties that span decades.
Who Offers the Best Warranties for Roof Replacements Near Bloomington?
Compare the best warranties for roof replacements to help you make an informed, confident decision for your house or business.
1. Equity Builders Roofing
Equity Builders Roofing is Bloomington’s go-to for its lifetime workmanship warranty, long-lasting materials and contractor expertise. This family-operated business brings 35 years of residential and commercial roofing competence and construction capabilities that may be necessary during a roof replacement project. This ensures you’re in safe hands should something come up during construction. The company’s labor warranty stands as long as the client owns the home. Meanwhile, the products and roofing systems they use are engineered for longevity and may last up to 50 years with proper maintenance.
Equity Builders Roofing also offers flexible financing options, with monthly payments starting at $89. The company’s transparent pricing model, paired with its price-match guarantee, positions it as a cost-effective option without compromising quality. Other strengths include:
- A+ Rating on Better Business Bureau (BBB)
- OSHA compliant
- Top of the House Certified Contractor
- Broad expertise in shingles, metal, rubber, cedar shake and low-slope systems
2. Cornerstone Roofing
Cornerstone Roofing is a trusted local contractor with over 20 years of experience in residential and commercial roofing projects. It emphasizes affordability, efficiency and long-term customer care.
The company is an Atlas Pro Plus Diamond Level certified installer — the highest credential offered by Atlas. It provides 50-year material warranties on shingle roofs, along with top-tier workmanship standards. Its comprehensive warranty coverage is paired with scheduled follow-ups to ensure continued roof performance. This rare certification places Cornerstone among Indiana’s elite roofing contractors, offering unmatched peace of mind backed by industry-leading manufacturer support.
- Atlas Pro Plus Diamond Level certified installer
- Installs shingle, metal and tile roofs
3. Sure Seal Contractors
Sure Seal Contractors delivers one of the most comprehensive roof replacement warranties in the Bloomington area, offering 50-year full coverage options that are among the strongest in the industry. As a CertainTeed Select ShingleMaster, the company is certified to install a wide range of roofing systems — including asphalt shingles, cedar shakes, composite shakes, rubber and metal roofs — with manufacturer-backed protection covering materials and labor.
Ever since its establishment in 2013, the company has put forth a customer-first approach, offering free roof tuneups, 24-hour turnaround on replacement proposals and financing options with 0% interest available. Some of its strengths include:
- OSHA Safety Certified
- Certain-Teed Select Shingle Master
- Certified to install asphalt, cedar shakes, composite shakes, rubber and metal roofs
4. AMI Roofing Contractors
AMI Roofing Contractors is another Bloomington warranty leader. It offers extended manufacturer warranties at no additional cost, earning the company statewide recognition from CertainTeed in 2024 as the top provider of upgraded warranty coverage. This locally owned and operated company serves Monroe County and surrounding areas.
It’s been in the industry for over 20 years, providing enhanced roofing warranties often unavailable through standard contractors. The company’s materials come from industry-leading brands like CertainTeed and Owens Corning, and a highly trained and credentialed team backs the workmanship. Other strengths include:
- BBB Accredited
- Certified CertainTeed ShingleMaster
- Materials from CertainTeed and Owens Corning
- Services include roofing, siding, guttering and repairs for both homes and businesses
5. 4 Good Reasons Roofing
4 Good Reasons Roofing is deeply rooted in the community as a family-run business. Clients receive a 10-year labor warranty on roofs, plus trusted manufacturer-backed coverage as an Owens Corning Preferred Contractor. While a relatively new company, the owner has extensive experience in the roofing industry and focuses on things that could be done better to ensure longevity.
While the 10-year labor warranty is solid, it’s more modest compared to the extended warranties offered by some competitors. Besides that, the company’s transparent pricing and great customer service make it a good choice for homeowners seeking a reliable residential roofing solution.
- Owens Corning Preferred Contractor
- Offers asphalt shingles, standing seam steel roofs, exposed fastener ribbed panel roofs, cedar shake roofs and flat roofing options
6. Oscar Roofing
Oscar Roofing is a family-owned roofing company that has been serving Indiana homeowners and businesses for over 20 years. As an Owens Corning Preferred Contractor, Oscar Roofing is authorized to offer manufacturer-backed warranties, giving clients peace of mind that materials and workmanship are supported by one of the industry’s most trusted brands. A five-year warranty covers roof replacements but can be extended for an extra fee.
Founded in 2003, Oscar Roofing has earned hundreds of positive reviews thanks to its thorough inspection process, which covers attic and ceiling damage, moisture issues, nail pops, decking integrity, roof walkability and flashing. The company also offers free inspections and works directly with insurance providers to simplify storm and hail damage claims.
- A+ Rating on BBB
- Owens Corning Preferred Contractor
- Awards from Expertise, Nextdoor and Best Roofer
- Free and extensive inspection
7. Ellerman Roofing
Ellerman Roofing is a locally owned company with 20 years of experience serving Indiana homeowners and businesses. It’s accredited by the Better Business Bureau and specializes in flat roofs and shingles. It offers labor warranties ranging from seven to 15 years — with longer coverage available on flat roofing projects.
While it doesn’t install metal roofs, it provides retrofit options to membrane systems when needed. The company is known for reliability and honest service and stands behind its work, though the warranty coverage is shorter and excludes manufacturer-backed protections.
- BBB-accredited
- Specializes in flat roofs and shingles
Benefits of a Strong Warranty
A strong warranty protects your home and budget long after the work is done. High-quality warranties often cover both materials and labor, reducing the risk of out-of-pocket expenses if issues arise. They also signal that contractors stand behind their work and partner with trusted manufacturers. Extended warranties can increase your property’s resale value and ensure support even in severe weather or installation defects.
Methodology
This list was compiled by evaluating roofing companies in the Bloomington area based on the strength and scope of their warranty offerings. Manufacturer-backed and labor warranties were considered, with special attention given to businesses providing extended or no-cost upgrades.
In addition to warranty coverage, material longevity, certification levels and each contractor’s overall reputation were assessed. Consumer-relevant features like transparent pricing, post-installation care and responsiveness to insurance claims were also taken into account to help homeowners make informed decisions.
| Company | Warranty | Certifications | Materials/Services | Notable Features |
| Equity Builders Roofing | Lifetime workmanship warranty,
Up to 50 years with proper maintenance of materials |
Top of the House Certified Contractor, A+ BBB | Shingles, metal, rubber, cedar shake, low-slope systems | 35 years experience, OSHA compliant, flexible financing, price-match guarantee |
| Cornerstone Roofing | 50-year material warranty (Atlas) | Atlas Pro Plus Diamond Level Installer | Residential & commercial roofing | High-tier certification, scheduled follow-ups, over 20 years experience |
| Sure Seal Contractors | 50-year full coverage of materials and labor | CertainTeed Select ShingleMaster, OSHA Safety | Asphalt, cedar shakes, composite shakes, rubber, metal roofs | Free roof tuneups, 24-hour proposal turnaround, 0% interest financing |
| AMI Roofing Contractors | Extended manufacturer warranties at no cost | Certified CertainTeed ShingleMaster, BBB Accredited | Roofing, siding, gutters, residential and commercial | Recognized by CertainTeed (2024), uses Owens Corning & CertainTeed materials |
| 4 Good Reasons Roofing | 10-year labor and manufacturer warranties | Owens Corning Preferred Contractor | Asphalt shingles, steel roofs, cedar shake, flat roofing | Transparent pricing, strong local focus, excellent customer service |
| Oscar Roofing | Five-year labor, extendable, plus manufacturer backing | Owens Corning Preferred Contractor, A+ BBB | Residential and commercial roofing, insurance claim support | Free detailed inspections, award-winning, over 20 years experience |
| Ellerman Roofing | Seven years for shingles to 15 years for flat roof labor | BBB Accredited | Shingles, flat roofs — no new metal, but can retrofit | Locally owned, honest service, limited manufacturer-backed warranties |
Get the Right Roof With Warranties That Work
The best warranties for roof replacement are those that give you complete peace of mind. Bloomington’s leading providers offer a wide range of options, whether you prefer solid 10-year labor guarantees or industry-leading 50-year manufacturer-backed coverage. When it’s time to replace your roof, look at more than the price. Consider the long-term promise.
